Project: Mixed-Use with Major Noise Issues Resolved
Whispering Pines delivered by QuietCoat
What is the project?
It is a high-end mixed-use project that features office buildings, restaurants, unique shops and luxury multi-family units with a hotel planned for the future. The building, with its striking architectural elements and thoughtful design, features first class amenities such as modern, sleek offices, a cutting-edge conference center and a state-of-the art fitness center
Who was involved?
Architect: Nelsen Partners
Acoustical Consultant: MD Acoustics
What was the challenge?
The company managing the development of the property, needed to eliminate the harsh wind-induced noise in the parking garage. During moderate wind events (winds at 10-35 mph), the aluminum panels in the garage exhibited a shrill, resonant shriek. The Principal of the development firm contacted acoustic consultants all over the world to help resolve the noise problem without success until he reached out to MD Acoustics, LLC in Chandler, AZ.
How was this the solution?
Mike Dickerson, Principal for MD Acoustics, selected QuietCoat® Acoustical Coating as the solution. “We went through a series of iterations to determine the best solution,” said Dickerson. “At the end of the day, we selected QuietCoat® as the most cost effective and best sound damping option based on project constraints.” Prior to moving forward with the acoustical coating, the acoustical engineering firm tested the product on a mock-up of the panel causing the noise and found that QuietCoat® mitigated the resonance.
What were the results?
Using QuietCoat® Acoustical Coating, MD Acoustics was able to eliminate the problem and silence the building, even during the windy monsoon season where wind speeds can reach 70+ miles per hour, according to Dickerson.
“With just two coats of QuietCoat® applied to the inside of the metal panels causing the vibration, the harsh noise was almost completely eliminated,” said the Principal of the development company. “QuietCoat® worked like a charm. We avoided a major nuisance for our tenants and helped create a more conducive environment.”
Beyond eliminating the noise, fewer coats of QuietCoat® were needed than originally thought to resolve the issue. “It was expected that multiple coats would be needed on both the inside and outside to quiet the noise,” said Dickerson. “Using only two coats on the inside saved costs and was safer for the client when applying the coating.” Since all the work was done on the interior side, there was no need to erect scaffolding or scale the outside of the structure.
“We also saved the owner a lot of money—literally salvaging the design of the building by providing QuietCoat® as the solution,” Dickerson added.
Acoustic Tests Performed
MD Acoustics performed acoustical and mechanical tests on the aluminum panels used in the garage to demonstrate the ability of QuietCoat® to solve the noise issue caused by the wind-induced panel resonance.
MD used acoustical beam forming techniques to measure the sound radiating from both untreated and treated panels. They used a SoundCam system to create a map of the noise while the panel was subjected to wind. The SoundCam uses microphones to map the location of noise sources in real time. This provides a visual representation of the areas of the panel that produce the most noise. Below are the results of the vibration tests.
The wind-noise phenomenon was replicated by towing the aluminum panel on a trailer at 30 mph. The SoundCam was positioned near the bed of the truck at approximately 10 feet from the attached trailer and panel mount. The measurement output is a video showing a color map of the loudest noise sources within the range of the camera.
The SoundCam results measured for the untreated panel shows the color contour, the loudest noise source, at approximately 92 dB in the center of the panel.
According to the SoundCam results, when the panel was treated with two coats of QuietCoat® the noise from the panel has sunk beneath the noise floor and the character of that noise has shifted such that the spectrum shows no distinct tones.
In addition to acoustical testing, MD also conducted a vibration test using a modal hammer and accelerometers to measure the frequency response of the aluminum panel. Vibration was also measured as it is the source of why sound and noise exist. When something vibrates and causes the air to make a pressure wave, we hear that pressure wave as “sound”.
Measurement of the vibration of the untreated plate minus the measurement of the treated plate, resulting in a “Vibration Loss” from 500 Hz to 10,000 Hz. There were 12 different locations where the accelerometer measured the vibration on the plate. The average dB vibration loss over the entire frequency range and for all locations was 9 dB.
The results show an average 12 dB vibration loss over the entire frequency range for location 1. A peak vibration loss of 52 dB at 8,280 Hz was achieved showing significant improvements in the harsh mid- to high-frequency range where the Watermark noise issue occurred.
The untreated and treated panel on the same chart showing visually the significant difference between the two vibration responses.
QuietCoat® is a sprayable, viscoelastic polymer coating, manufactured by PABCO® Gypsum, that reduces noise and vibration with minimum weight, bulk and cost. QuietCoat® is engineered specifically for coating nonporous materials including stainless steel, galvanized iron, aluminum and composite (reinforced plastic) materials.
Learn more about QuietCoat here.
Transforming the RAFFLES Hotel
The RAFFLES Hotel in Singapore is a beautiful, luxury heritage building. commARCH speaks to Simon Thompson, Executive Director and Dennis ...
2021 FGIA Virtual Annual Conference
The Fenestration and Glazing Industry Alliance (FGIA) will hold its 2021 Annual Conference virtually due to the continued health concerns around the spread of COVID-19.
WHY DO WE FEEL BETTER WITH WOOD?
This commARCH White Paper focuses on how Wood shows psychological and physiological benefits, according to research.